Uber vs. Lyft Driver: Which is Better?

The post Uber vs. Lyft Driver: Which is Better? appeared first on Millennial Money.

The time has come for you to make money as a rideshare driver. However, given the limited amount of rideshare platforms and conflicting reviews, you might feel confused when trying to decide which one to join.

As you probably know, Uber and Lyft are the world’s most popular ridesharing apps. While they’re pretty similar overall, there are several noteworthy differences.

To help guide your decision, this post dives into how they stack up.

For starters, let’s answer the most important question.

Which App Pays Drivers More?

It’s almost a tie. 

On average, Uber drivers earn $16.77 per hour versus $16.33 with Lyft. Average earnings per mile come to $0.81 for Uber and $0.75 for Lyft. And earnings per trip amount to $10.58 for Uber and $10.02 for Lyft.

One reason why Uber drivers typically earn a bit more is that Uber drivers tend to spend more time on the road. According to Gridwise, there’s a 4% difference in trips per hour between Uber and Lyft. So if your goal is to maximize driving time, Uber may be the better way to go.

That said, there are a lot of factors that affect how much you can earn on each platform, which we will explore next.

Key Factors That Influence Pay

Location

When it comes to pay, location is the most significant piece of the puzzle. According to Second Measure, Uber brings in the lion’s share of the U.S. rideshare market, generating 72% of spending.

But in certain areas of the country, Lyft is way more popular. As it turns out, riders are more likely to use Lyft on the West Coast or Midwest than in the Northeast. And in January 2021, Lyft took in 44% of rideshare sales in Phoenix and Detroit—its highest percentage among the 15 most populous U.S. cities.

With that in mind, make sure to pay attention to your local market instead of national averages. One easy way to do this is downloading both companies’ customer-facing apps and reviewing how many drivers are circling in your area.

Average Trip Cost 

Uber and Lyft are both still adjusting to the post-pandemic economy—and customers are feeling the pinch.

The main reason for this is because demand for rides plummeted during the peak of the pandemic. As a result, many drivers went on to find other work.

Due to ridesharing being a demand-driven, market-based model, fewer drivers on the road means more competition for rides—and higher prices for riders.

Second Measure found that Lyft’s average transaction value was $26 in August 2021, which was a whopping 47% year-over-year jump. In comparison, Uber’s average transaction value per ride was $20, reflecting a 20% increase from the previous year.

When prices spike, customers usually push back. Most rideshare customers use both apps and toggle between them to get lower pricing. And if prices get too far out of control, customers are more likely to rent cars, carpool, bike, or use public transportation to get around.

This impacts drivers because it means fewer passengers on the road and heavier competition with rideshare hustlers who are competing for pickups.

For this reason, it’s a good idea to monitor pricing fluctuations over time. If you’re having trouble finding customers in your area, Lyft or Uber’s pricing could be the cause.

While you can’t control how much the companies charge, you can decide where, when, and who you drive for.

Commissions

Unfortunately, pricing spikes don’t always lead to stronger profits for drivers because both companies take in high commissions.

While Uber drivers typically generate higher hourly pay, the company takes 25% of the total fare. In comparison, Lyft only takes 20% of the total fare.

In reality, Uber and Lyft commissions are often much higher, in the 30% to 40% range, after factoring in extra charges like airport fees and safety fees.

The key lesson here is that it isn’t just about how much you earn with Uber and Lyft. It’s also about how much you keep. Both companies collect a fair amount of money from commissions at the expense of their drivers.

On top of that, Uber and Lyft drivers also have to fork over a significant amount of expenses in gas and car maintenance. And while there are some discount options available (more on that below), these costs still fall squarely on drivers.

There are also taxes to consider. As an Uber or Lyft driver, you work as an independent contractor. This means you have to pay the government a hefty chunk of whatever you bring in. This includes federal taxes, payroll taxes, and state taxes, depending on where you live.

Winner: Uber 

With all of the above factors in mind, Uber’s 72% market share and higher hourly rate give it the earning potential edge for most drivers. So out of the two, I would pick Uber when considering total earnings averages.

Next, let’s take a looko at how the platforms compare when it’s time to collect your dough.

Cashing Out with Uber and Lyft

Both Uber and Lyft issue weekly payments by default, and it’s easy to link your checking account in both apps to receive payment. If you go with the weekly payment option, it won’t cost you anything to cash out. But you’ll have to wait at least a week for your money to land in your checking account.

Uber Instant Pay

To streamline payments, Uber has Instant Pay, which lets you cash out instantly up to five times per day. But there’s a catch.

Uber charges $0.50 each time you use Instant Pay. If you cash out multiple times throughout a shift, you could lose up to $2.50 daily in fees. That being the case, you’re much better off using the service just once per day to avoid fees.

Uber Debit Card

As a work-around, Uber provides a free, exclusive debit card for drivers through a partnership with GoBank. If you sign up, you can cash out for free up to five times daily. You also get 1% cash back on all purchases, 3% cash back at Exxon and Mobil stations, 10% cash back at Advance Auto, and a 15% discount on select services at Jiffy Lube. 

Lyft Express Pay

Lyft has a very similar payment system called Express Pay, which also charges a $0.50 fee for each transfer.

Lyft Direct Debit Card

To avoid that fee, you can apply for a Lyft Direct debit card and receive payments instantly after every ride without paying any fees.

Lyft Direct also issues cash back and savings rebates. You can earn 1% on gas and groceries, 2% back on gas at select locations, 4% back on dining, and 1% on a bonus rotating category every month.

Plus, the card doesn’t have any low balance or maintenance fees.

Winner: Uber

As you can see, the cash-out process is almost identical for both two companies. But between the two, Uber takes the cake because its debit card currently offers 3% cash back at Exxon and Mobil, versus 2% for gas at select locations with Lyft.

One % might not seem like a big difference, but trust me, it adds up—especially if you live in an area where gas is expensive (e.g., New York or Los Angeles).

Using Uber and Lyft’s debit cards should be a no-brainer for serious drivers. The services don’t cost anything, and you can receive your money instantly. Sign up and thank me later.

Comparing the Eligibility Requirements

Thanks to their user-friendly apps, Uber and Lyft make it super easy for new drivers to sign up.

The application process is straightforward for both companies. It’s just a matter of providing your name and contact information and entering the city where you want to drive.

However, you will need to pass a couple of basic eligibility requirements to drive. These rules are intended to keep both passengers, drivers, and the general public safe.

Driver Eligibility Requirements

Uber Driver Eligibility Requirements

• Have a valid drivers license, insurance, inspection, and registration
• Have at least one year of experience as a licensed driver or three years if you’re under 23 years old
• Meet your city’s minimum age requirements 
• Demonstrate proof of residency
• Own a functioning smartphone

Lyft Driver Eligibility Requirements 

• Be able to produce a valid driver’s license, insurance, inspection, and registration
• Meet your city’s minimum age requirements
• Demonstrate proof of residency
• Own a functioning smartphone

Background checks

If you want to drive for Uber or Lyft, you’ll have to pass a background check through Checkr, a third-party verification service.

Most people should pass this with flying colors. But there are a few common disqualifying factors for Uber and Lyft that could make it difficult or impossible to secure work.

For example, you may be ineligible for Uber or Lyft if you’ve been convicted of a crime or if you’ve gotten a DUI. You may also be ineligible if you have a disqualifying theft or property damage offense in the last seven years.

After passing the background check, you’ll also have to maintain a clean driving record to continue driving for both platforms.

Vehicle Requirements 

You don’t need a brand-new car. But you will need a safe and somewhat modern vehicle to drive for both Uber and Lyft. You’re also more likely to get better tips if your ride looks nice, so that’s something to consider.

With this in mind, let’s take a closer look at the specific vehicle requirements for both platforms.

Lyft Vehicle Requirements 

• No taxis or limousines
• Must meet local city or state standards
• Must have at least five seatbelts and a maximum of eight
• Rentals must go through the Express Drive program
• Accepts subcompact vehicles 

Uber Vehicle Requirements 

• Must have at least four doors and transport a minimum of four passengers 
• Must be 15 years old or newer 
• Title cannot be salvaged, rebuilt, or reconstructed 
• Rentals must come from an Uber-approved company
• Can’t have cosmetic damage, missing pieces, taxi paint jobs, or commercial branding

Winner: It’s a Tie

As long as you have a clean record and a decent car, you shouldn’t have any trouble signing up for Uber or Lyft. Neither company will judge you on skill or experience—or even ask for any referrals for that matter.

Taking a step back, working with rideshare companies (and in the gig economy in general), is much different than applying to a traditional job.

There are usually lower barriers to entry which make these gigs ideal for those looking for a side hustle or who are just starting out in their careers.

Comparing the Navigation Maps

When driving for a rideshare service, the map you use means everything. It’s arguably the most important tool because your map is responsible for getting you from place to place as quickly as possible.

In light of this, let’s see how Uber and Lyft’s maps compare before you hit the road.

Uber Nav  

Uber Nav is a built-in, proprietary GPS navigation system that pulls data from third-party GPS services such as Google Maps, TomTom, and Bing Maps.

Uber Nav is solid overall and comes with some handy features like night mode and lane guidance. It’s not quite as advanced as Waze, but you can opt to use Waze or Google Maps if you prefer. To do this, simply select your default navigation app in settings.

The main issue with using a third-party map in the Uber app is that you have to toggle between the two programs. The last thing you want to be doing is fumbling around with your phone when you’re driving passengers.

Lyft Navigation

Lyft also has a default map, called Lyft Navigation, which runs on Google Maps.

My favorite thing about Lyft Navigation is that it’s intuitive and easy to understand. For example, the app senses when your vehicle is in motion and changes to a simpler map format to minimize distractions.

To access additional features when driving, simply select “More” in the menu below the map. For example, you can report an emergency or view the details on your last ride.

Lyft Navigation also supports Waze. But just like with Uber, you’ll have to switch navigation preferences in the Lyft app.

Winner: Lyft

Lyft Navigation wins because it’s easier to use than Uber Nav and keeps things simple by pulling its GPS data from Google Maps. As a result, Lyft Navigation makes it a little easier to focus on the road, and you can’t put a price tag on that.

Uber and Lyft Ride Modes 

The ride options you have on both platforms are numerous. Here’s a breakdown of each one.

Lyft Ride Modes 

Lyft 

Lyft is the standard driving option that can accommodate up to three riders at a time.

Lyft Shared

Lyft Shared lets customers share a car with other riders heading in the same direction. As a driver, this can mean longer trips and more tips due to numerous drop-off locations.

Wait & Save

Wait & Save lets customers order a ride and lock in a lower price during busy times. For drivers, the benefit is that you’ll know your schedule ahead of time. The downside is that you can potentially miss out on surge pricing.

Priority Pickup

Priority Pickup allows customers to request an expedited pickup. The service costs slightly more to customers, meaning more money for drivers.

Preferred 

Lyft Preferred gives riders an upgraded experience, with nicer cars, more legroom, and top-rated drivers. As a driver, you can earn more with Preferred rides, but you’ll need to meet the following conditions:

• Your car must be model year 2015 or newer.
• Your car must be impeccably clean.
• You must have a driver rating of at least 4.9+ stars.
• You must have completed over 300 trips.

Lyft Lux

Lyft Lux is the company’s luxury top-tier ride service that has three different levels. Here is how to qualify as a driver:

• Lyft Lux: You must have a high-end sedan or SUV with four seats and a leather interior.
• Lux Black: You must have a luxury car with a black exterior, leather interior, and at least four seats.
• Lux Black XL: You must drive a luxury SUV with a black exterior, leather interior, and seating for up to six.

Uber Ride Modes 

UberX

UberX is Uber’s standard, private rideshare option and the most common ride model that drivers encounter.

Uber Pool 

Uber Pool lets customers share rides with other passengers. The benefit to passengers is that they can save a few bucks while drivers get longer trips and hopefully more tips.

Uber Comfort

Uber Comfort is an upgraded experience for customers, offering rides in newer cars with extra legroom. Drivers earn more money for each trip.

Here’s how to qualify:

• You must complete at least 500 trips.
• You must have a driver rating of at least 4.85.
• Your car must be eligible and less than seven years old.

Uber Green

Uber Green provides rides in sustainable electric vehicles. If you drive an EV, you’ll likely automatically qualify for this drive mode.

The main financial benefit to drivers is that you’ll earn an extra $0.50 for each trip.

Uber Premium

Uber Premium offers rides with top-rated drivers in luxury vehicles. To qualify as a driver, you must complete over 20 trips and have an average rating of 4.6 or higher. Your vehicle also needs to be eligible. Check out the full list of eligible vehicles.

Uber Black

Uber Black (and Uber Black SUV) is the closest thing that Uber offers to a traditional high-end livery or black car service. Drivers can earn significantly more money per trip, but it’s not easy making the cut.

Here’s what it takes to qualify as a driver:

• You must be insured to drive commercially.
• You must meet all state- or local-level livery regulations.
• You must maintain a driver rating of at least 4.85 stars.
• You must drive a luxury car with leather seats.

UberXL 

UberXL is the ride mode for groups of up to six people. Drivers earn more per trip and need to drive either a minivan or large SUV that seats at least five passengers.

Uber WAV

Uber WAV is available in select markets and provides rides to people that need to bring along their wheelchair or motorized scooter.

Drivers must complete special training that focuses on helping passengers enter and exit their vehicles. Drivers are also expected to go the extra mile to assist passengers with walkers, canes, and other assistive devices.

Winner: Uber 

As you can see, Uber offers a wider variety of ride options for drivers and, therefore, more earning opportunities. For this reason, Uber wins the ride mode category.

Which Company Is Cooler to Work For?

Most drivers are worried about dollars and cents, and rightfully so. However, it’s worth considering how the cultures of each company compare.

You probably know that Uber has a long list of scandals under its belt, including sexual harassment and ethics claims. For example, Uber once infamously poached 50 employees from Carnegie Mellon’s robotics lab.

Lyft positions itself as a cooler alternative to Uber. Most notably, the company makes a point to be more welcoming and community-oriented than its rival.

The Winner: Lyft

Lyft’s reputation is cleaner than Uber’s is, and it has a more fun vibe to boot. Also, I’m all in for companies that take a stand and aren’t afraid to be outspoken about what they believe in.

To be fair, Uber is trying to clean up its act. And if you dig beneath the surface, you’ll find dirt on both companies. The best advice I can give is to do your research and see which company aligns with your values.

Learn More:

• The 34 Best Side Hustles for Men 
• 13 Best Side Hustles for Couples
• 14 Best Side Hustles for Women
• How to Start a Side Hustle: Your Guide to Making Extra Income

Food Delivery 

Uber and Lyft both make it easy to switch from driving passengers to making deliveries. 

Let’s take a closer look at how the services compare.

Lyft Delivery 

Lyft Delivery partners with businesses that require local delivery services.

Lyft drivers can make money picking up deliveries and dropping them off for customers. With Lyft, you can deliver a variety of items including food, retail items, prescriptions, and auto parts.

Lyft Delivery requests appear like passenger ride requests in the app. It will say “delivery” as the ride type and give you the option of whether you want to accept it. In addition, you’ll see the total amount that you’ll earn for the delivery before you accept it.

The only downside is that Lyft Delivery is only available in major cities, including Austin, Atlanta, Texas, Houston, Indianapolis, Florida, Orlando, San Francisco, Phoenix, San Diego, San Antonio, and Seattle.

Uber Eats

Uber Eats is Uber’s food delivery service, available in over 500 locations throughout the U.S. Here’s the full list of available locations.

Once you’re up and running, you can easily enable delivery requests in the Driver app menu. 

It’s worth noting that Uber Eats recently acquired Postmates, so we can expect to see many more delivery options beyond food in the near future.

Winner: Uber Eats

Uber Eats is the better choice for food deliveries because its accessible to millions of additional drivers than Lyft Delivery. I also expect the earning opportunities with Uber Eats to grow due to its Postmates acquisition.

Uber vs. Lyft Driver Benefits 

Rideshare services like Uber and Lyft don’t typically provide comprehensive benefits packages for drivers. But there are still some perks that you can access.

Here’s a look at how driver benefits measure up for both companies.

Bonuses 

Lyft Bonus Opportunities

Lyft occasionally offers real-time bonuses in the Driver app, depending on rider demand.

Scheduled bonuses may also appear in the Driver app at the beginning of the week, helping you plan your driving schedule accordingly.

Ride Streaks 

Ride Streaks are multiple-ride bonuses that you can rack up by accepting back-to-back rides during busy times, such as weekday commute hours and holidays.

Personal Power Zones

A Personal Power Zone is a type of single-ride bonus that may appear when there are more passengers than available drivers in a specific area. The map will display these zones when they are available.

Earnings Guarantees

Earnings Guarantees allow you to collect a set amount of money for completing several rides in a set amount of time. Earn less than the guaranteed rate, and Lyft covers the difference.

Ride Challenges

A Ride Challenge is a multiple-ride bonus for completing a set number of rides during a specific timeframe. For example, you might have to complete 10 rides between Monday and Friday to earn $25.

Uber Bonus Opportunities

Uber doesn’t contain as many in-app promotions as Lyft. But there are still a few that you can access from time to time.

Quest 

Quest lets you make extra money by completing a target amount of trips in a set period of time. For example, you might earn an extra $30 by completing 30 trips over a week.

Consecutive Trips 

Driving at busy times can also generate more rewards. With the Consecutive Trips plan, you can make extra money for completing a series of extra trips without canceling, going offline, or rejecting a trip.

Promotions

Lyft Promotions

Lyft currently has a promotion promising $3,000 if you give 170 rides in your first 30 days of service. This is an awesome incentive if you’re looking to hustle. Use the promo code LYFTMAX 3000.

You can also receive a bonus for referring a driver. This bonus depends on a few different factors, which Lyft outlines here.

Uber Promotions

Uber doesn’t have any new driver promotions at the time of writing. It does have a new driver referral promotion. Just like with Lyft, the actual referral bonus can vary.

Rewards 

Lyft Rewards

Lyft Rewards is a driver recognition program that provides kickbacks for superior service and dedication. Drivers get access to exclusive features and savings opportunities on things like car repairs, tax services, and roadside assistance.

Uber Pro

Uber Pro is a loyalty program for drivers and comes with benefits like discounts on fuel and car maintenance, priority pickups at airports, and roadside assistance.

In addition, qualifying Uber Pro drivers can receive 100% tuition coverage at Arizona State University (ASU) online. This benefit can also be transferred to an eligible family member. If you ask me, this is one of the coolest perks you can find in the gig economy.

Winner: Lyft

If your primary goal is making money, Lyft’s $3,000 new driver bonus is the best benefit—hands down. However, if you’re serious about taking online university courses, Uber’s ASU tuition coverage can far outweigh any money that you make by driving cars.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Is Driving as a Side Hustle Worth It?

It largely depends on where and how much you’re driving. If you make this a full-time job, you will spend a lot of money on gas and on wear and tear.

After factoring that in, plus commission fees, you can quickly see why rideshare driving isn’t the most profitable or scalable side hustle. But it’s definitely legit, and it can be a fun way to earn some extra cash—and you can meet some incredible people along the way.

From my perspective, driving for Uber or Lyft is better as a part-time gig.

Does Driving for Uber or Lyft Affect Your Insurance Coverage?

Yes. Your auto insurance will most likely increase when driving for Uber or Lyft. Talk to your insurance company to figure out a plan that fits your needs and budget.

Remember: The more time you spend on the road, the greater the likelihood of getting into a fender bender or serious accident—especially in congested areas with a lot of traffic. That being the case, it pays to have adequate protection.

Does Uber Use Surge Pricing?

Uber uses surge pricing at various times. In general, Uber costs more for prime time service, during rush hour or on weekends or holidays. The good news is that drivers can earn much more money during these times.

Does Lyft Have a Driver Rating System?

Yes. Lyft always asks customers to rate the driver after a ride. If the customer doesn’t rate the driver, the app automatically issues a five-star rating.

The Bottom Line

Rideshare driving for both Uber and Lyft is a proven way to bring in some extra dough, where and when you want. In my opinion, both companies are worth driving for as side hustles.

Furthermore, there’s a high demand to recruit new drivers due to a massive driver shortage. At Uber, the issue is so bad that the company is launching a $250 million stimulus program to encourage more signups. Lyft is also covering rental car costs and giving $800 stimulus payments to drivers.

When you’re ready to drive, I suggest keeping both apps open on your phone so you can take the highest-paying rides that come your way. Pay attention to local pricing trends to maximize your earnings.

As one last piece of advice, it’s easy to go overboard comparing rideshare apps. By this point, you should be ready to pick a company and apply. You can always optimize your strategy later. And remember, there’s no rule that says you can’t work for both companies.

Whichever side hustle you choose, here’s to finding the one that helps you achieve your financial goals—and lets you have fun along the way!

The post Uber vs. Lyft Driver: Which is Better? appeared first on Millennial Money.